You are going to hear about it

Brian Burton
September 03, 2009
By Brian Burton
By the time you read this article the entries in the $1 million “Zerofootprint Building Re-Skinning Competition” will be in the capable hands of eight judges. I won’t be surprised in the least if the general public hears a lot more about glass and glazing than it ever has. That’s partly because the competition is specifically designed to generate publicity and “jumpstart” interest in the concept.

There is also a very good reason that professionals in the glass industry should be aware of this competition: competitors intend to retrofit five occupied buildings and monitor the energy performance for three years. Take my word for it – you’re going to hear a lot about it. Unfortunately for the sponsors and 28 experts appointed to advise the competition organizers – I suspect it won’t all be good news.

A glazed double facade (GDF) can be defined as two layers of insulated glass separated by a significant amount of air space, that is to say, a second glass facade is placed in front of the first. These two envelopes act as insulation in theory by enabling the air to circulate in the cavity. In some cases the ventilation of the cavity is controlled by fans or openings. The envelopes are not necessarily airtight and automated equipment, such as shading devices, are often installed. We are also starting to see “hybrid” systems with materials other than glass and as a result the term GDF may not be applicable for very long.

I recently surveyed the existing literature that has been written about these incredibly complex building systems and discovered what amounts to a tremendous amount of speculation about their performance in both new and retrofit construction. By the way, the idea is not new. It has been around for more than 100 years and the concept actually predates insulating glass. Only recently have I heard people refer to the concept as “re-skinning.”

The key performance issues are safety, stability, occupant comfort, acoustics, energy efficiency, control strategies, air quality/ventilation, daylighting, maintenance/cleaning and cost.

Until recently there were very few articles written that provided an independent review of these systems. Dr. Karl Gertis, director of the Fraunhofer Institute of Building Physics in Germany, wrote the most comprehensive and is considered the leading expert on the subject.

He concedes that they have become very fashionable; however, his article really knocks the wind out of the sails of the people who have been actively promoting these systems, to the surprise of many.

To start with, in North America they can be four times as expensive as a conventional building envelope. He also states that in spite of all the claims made about improved energy efficiency in the buildings they should in fact be rated as energy guzzlers.

He also states that computer simulations cannot be relied on, practical measurement results are lacking and apart from a few special cases, they are unsuitable from a building physics point of view. Moreover, they are much too expensive and most of the performance claims that have been published have proven to be wrong or untrue.

He notes that the arguments against these systems are much more important than the arguments for them.

He was referring to new construction. When you get into the field of retrofitting double facades, life will get even more complicated as I suspect the organizers of the competition will soon discover. First of all, 30-year-old buildings will demonstrate defects as a result of their service life and will require a complete audit as well as repairs.

Secondly, as I was taught early in my career, it’s not considered good practice to carry out untested experiments on occupied buildings.

And lastly, I have read that the average tenant has a tolerance of about one day when it comes to maintenance and construction retrofit activity. In other words, if you can’t accomplish the task in one 12-hour shift, you are going to hear about it.


Brian Burton is the business development manager for Can-Best (www.Can-Best.com) and is a frequent contributor to industry trade publications in the field of building science. He can be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Subscription Centre

 
New Subscription
 
Already a Subscriber
 
Customer Service
 
View Digital Magazine Renew


Coming Events

2020 FGIA Annual Conference
February 10-13, 2020
CSC Building Expo 2020
February 26, 2020
GlassBuild America 2020
September 15-17, 2020

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website. By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. To find out more, read our Privacy Policy.